Skip to main content

Women Doctors in Orkney… what do we know about them?

This was a question I’d been pondering, after researching the life of a woman doctor who worked on North Ronaldsay, between 1930 and 1946.

Beatrice Garvie was her name.

I knew about her from the North Ronaldsay Archive, which displays many of her superb photographs of island life, and in which I had been delighted to find her pictures of my own family.

Thomson family at South Ness, Jenny Sanderson, nee Thomson, seated left, with baby on lap. This is Ray Sanderson, Fiona's Father.  Reference D156/0239 Orkney Library and Archive.

Over the last few years, I have worked with islanders who still hold her in living memory, to document the people in the more than 500 photographs, and, where possible, to note the events and places that are in them too. These photographs are held by the Orkney Archive.

At the same time, I was looking into other Archives, to see what I could find about Dr Garvie. The more I found, the more I realised what an incredible life she had led. She was one of the earliest women doctors to train in Scotland, and she qualified even before she could be awarded a degree - before 1900, so before women won the vote, before the First World War, at a time when it was unusual for a woman to be seen riding a bicycle!

How, I wondered, did women like Doctor Garvie manage all this? To move against a cultural tide requires support, doesn’t it…. Where was hers coming from? And this was how I came to wonder, could I find out something more about her. Did she stay in touch with the other women she trained with? Did they help each other to find employment? Were they also involved with suffrage and other movements for social change?

In my first researches, I had come across a book, ‘Les Femmes Docteurs’; written in French, and published in 1901, which documented women doctors working around the world. Marvellously, it included lists of names. So I knew from this that in 1900, there were already three women doctors working in Orkney…three!

Mary Baird Hannay, on Flotta, (p.169) and J.A. Craig and K. Hogg listed simply as working ‘à Orkney’ (p.170).

 Were there local records about these women in the Archive? Feeling the need for a support network of my own, I invited people who were interested to come and get involved, just in case we might find any more women’s names alongside Hannay, Craig, Hogg, and Garvie.

So, over the Winter of 2023, a group of us rolled up our sleeves to see what we could find. We began to research individual doctors and island records, alongside broader social themes, and the field of medicine itself.  

This blog covers something of what we found.

And it is astonishing.

Dr Beatrice Garvie (right) with a visitor, Marion Taylor,
on North Ronaldsay. Both are holding cameras!

Blog post written and researched by Fiona Sanderson, project leader.

References

The photos used in this blog post are held in the Archive of the Orkney Library and Archive, Kirkwall.

‘Les Femmes Docteurs’, 1901, (3rd edition). Alliance Co-operative du Livre. Paris.
Link to ‘In Search of Beatrice Garvie’ 
Link to Beatrice Garvie photograph selection,





Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Dr Jean McPhail/Cursiter – Papa Westray 1926 to 1945 - Dramatic Rescue

Injured Woman’s Terrible Flight. Marooned and helpless on Papa Westray. Rowing Boat’s Hazardous Voyage. On 25 November 1931, Dr Jean Cursiter left Papa Westray to accompany a seriously injured patient on a hazardous and extraordinary journey to hospital in Kirkwall.[1] She left behind her husband Ian and 8 month old son, Jack. It's unlikely she would return for some days given the stormy weather. Jessie Groat's hand had been caught in a threshing machine, and although the machine was stopped immediately, the limb was crushed and lacerated to the elbow. Her husband, farmer Thomas Groat, of Howe summoned Dr Cursiter who attended to the injury but realised the case was so serious it needed an immediate operation if Mrs Groat was to survive. Papa Westray was completely cut off from any help or rescue. The island had no telegraph or telephone communication to summon help from Kirkwall on the Orkney Mainland.   The sea was rough and dangerous for a small boat to cross. The Orkney...

Dr Jean McPhail/Cursiter – Papa Westray 1926 to 1945 Part 1

 An earlier post detailed the challenges that the island of Papa Westray (known locally as Papay) had experienced since 1896 in trying to get a local Resident Medical Officer. Prior to that the doctor from Westray had to be rowed over.  Once Papay had secured funding for a resident doctor they found it was very hard to recruit them, and they often didn’t stay.  Many were young women doctors, newly qualified in Glasgow and Edinburgh and found the lack of transport and housing made it intolerable for them to remain on the island.  Link to earlier post One woman doctor was the exception to this.  She arrived in 1926 and stayed until 1945. Dr Jean McPhail had previous experience of Orkney and islands and this likely informed her decision to apply for the job on Papay.   Also by this time a house for the doctor had been built, complete with surgery. Island life clearly suited her as she became fully involved in the community, married a local man and ...

Open Day March 2026

Photo: Andrea Massey On 21 March, the Orkney Women Doctors Research Group (OWDRG) held an “Open Day” in the MacGillivray Room at the   Orkney Library & Archive. This followed on from an exhibition last year, at the Pier Arts Centre, and in North Ronaldsay which looked at the career of Dr Beatrice Garvie, who worked in North Ronaldsay in the 1930s and ‘40s. Since then, the group have continued to research the early women doctors; so far more than fifty. The aim of the Open Day was to showcase our research so far. We also hoped to hear some more memories and stories of these early women doctors and their time in Orkney. We had a steady stream of visitors during the day who showed a keen interest in the project and our research to date. Thanks to all those who came, we really enjoyed chatting with you. Here are a few photos from the Open Day: Our OWDRG quilt details all of the early women doctors found so far and where they were located. This is a work in progress, and ...